The Truth About Tithing: How the Church Turned an Old Jewish Law into Christian Obligation

Tithing Exposed reveals how the postmodern church transformed an ancient Jewish law into a Christian requirement. Discover the history of tithing, the truth behind church giving, and why generosity has been redefined by modern church leaders.

The Tithe Question

Few topics stir more debate in modern Christianity than tithing. For some, it’s a sacred duty — a non-negotiable ten percent owed to God. For others, it’s a heavy burden, a practice that seems more about funding church programs than fostering genuine generosity. But what if the idea of tithing, as preached in many pulpits today, was never meant for the church at all?

The uncomfortable truth is that tithing began as a Jewish law under the Old Covenant, not as a universal command for Christians. Yet in the postmodern church, it has been rebranded as an essential act of faith, often tied to promises of blessing or warnings of curses.

The Origin of Tithing: A Jewish Practice

Tithing was central to Israel’s covenant law. The people of Israel gave a tenth of their produce and livestock to support the Levitical priesthood, who had no land inheritance of their own (Numbers 18:21). It was never primarily about money; it was about sustaining the temple system and the priests who mediated between God and His people.

Importantly, there wasn’t just one tithe. Historical and biblical records show multiple tithes — some for the priests, some for festivals, and some for the poor. In total, the system was far more complex than the simple “ten percent” often preached today.

From Law to Obligation: How the Church Adopted Tithing

Fast forward to the rise of the institutional church. As Christianity spread and church structures grew, leaders needed sustainable financial systems. What better model than the ancient tithe?

By the 4th century, tithing had become a formal expectation in many regions, not because the New Testament demanded it, but because the church needed resources to build, govern, and expand. Over time, this practice was solidified into tradition, carrying with it the weight of divine obligation — even though Jesus and the apostles never commanded it for believers.

The Postmodern Twist: Tithing and Greed

In today’s postmodern church, tithing often functions less as a biblical principle and more as a financial strategy. Countless sermons tie giving to prosperity, suggesting that failing to tithe invites curses while faithful giving guarantees blessings.

This transactional view of God distorts both the gospel and generosity. Instead of free, Spirit-led giving rooted in love, believers are pressured into a system that mirrors the old covenant law — one Jesus fulfilled and set aside.

What the New Testament Actually Teaches About Giving

The New Testament never commands Christians to tithe. Instead, it emphasizes:

Generosity as an act of love (2 Corinthians 9:7 — “God loves a cheerful giver”).

Equality and care for the poor (2 Corinthians 8:13–15).

Voluntary, Spirit-led giving rather than obligation (Acts 2:44–45).

The focus shifts from percentages to hearts, from law to liberty, from compulsion to cheerful sacrifice.

Why do churches preach generosity… but pressure people into fear-based giving?

Why do some religious empires grow richer… while faithful givers stay poor?

Let’s uncover what really happened—biblically and historically.

Tithing in the Bible: Food, Not Funds

The original tithe wasn’t money. It was food—grain, wine, oil, livestock—shared to support those without land: the Levites (Numbers 18:21-24).

✔ It was a welfare system, not a wealth grab.

✔ It fed the poor, strangers, widows, and orphans (Deuteronomy 14:28-29).

✔ It was given once every three years to care for the vulnerable—not every Sunday to fund luxuries.

Hidden Gem: Malachi 3:10 says, “Bring meat into my house,” not “money into my treasury.”

Another shocker?

Malachi wasn’t even addressing church members—he rebuked corrupt priests who robbed God by not tithing themselves.

The Turning Point: From Sacred Gift to Religious Tax

The major shift came after the church merged with the Roman Empire in the 4th century.

Under Constantine and later rulers, tithing evolved from voluntary giving to mandatory taxation.

Clergy stopped working in fields. Church buildings became grand. Bishops wielded political power. Ordinary people were forced to give 10%—or face spiritual threats like excommunication.

Outcome?

• The poor got poorer.

• The church got richer—amassing land, gold, and political influence.

Jesus Never Preached Tithing to His Followers

Surprised? You should be.

Jesus never asked His disciples to pay tithes.

He called out greedy religious leaders (Matthew 23:23), praised humble givers (Mark 12:41-44), and focused on justice, mercy, and faith.

Paul followed the same path:

• “Give what you’ve decided in your heart.” (2 Corinthians 9:7)
• “Not under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.”

The Prosperity Gospel—Selling False Hope

Fast forward to today… some churches dangle false promises:

“Give 10%—God will make you rich.”
“Empty your pockets—unlock heaven’s financial blessings.”

It sounds spiritual… but it’s not Scriptural.

✔ The early church didn’t tithe—they gave joyfully, sacrificially, helping the needy (Acts 2:44-45).
✔ No apostle taught giving to get rich—they taught generosity to glorify God and uplift others.

The Real Purpose of Giving: A New Covenant Standard

• True giving flows from love, not fear.
• It’s about people, not property.
• It’s heart-led, not pulpit-pressured.

What does New Testament giving look like?

— Feed the hungry.
— Help the needy.
— Support true ministry that actually feeds your soul—not one that threatens your peace.
— Give by choice—not by force.

The Summary Most Churches Won’t Tell You

✔ Tithing under Moses: Food to support priests and the poor.
✔ Tithing in Malachi: Correction to corrupt priests—not the public.
✔ Tithing after Christ: Fulfilled and replaced by freewill, Spirit-led giving.
✔ Modern misuse: Manipulation, false promises, and guilt tactics to enrich religious systems.

The truth is simple:
God isn’t impressed by percentages—He delights in cheerful, honest, love-driven generosity.

Real giving helps people, not enriches empires.
It frees hearts—it doesn’t enslave wallets.

Now, if this spoke to you,

Comment to share your thoughts and views on the comment section.

Why This Matters Today

When the church enforces tithing as law, it risks placing believers back under a system of fear and guilt. More dangerously, it fuels greed-driven leadership that thrives on financial control.

Exposing this doesn’t mean Christians should stop giving. On the contrary, the call is to embrace a New Covenant model of generosity — one rooted in love, freedom, and stewardship, not in legalistic percentages.

Beyond the Tithe

The truth is clear: tithing was a Jewish law, not a Christian command. Its adoption into the postmodern church reveals more about institutional survival than biblical fidelity.

Christ’s call isn’t for us to return to the law that he fulfilled, but to live as generous people transformed by grace. True giving flows not from obligation, but from gratitude.

African Christianity: It Didn’t Come From Europe—It Came From Pentecost

The Desert Fathers of Egypt: The Wilderness Revival That Shaped the Church

The Early Church Worshiped in Deserts, Caves and Catacombs: A Lessons For The Postmodern Church

Does God Need Your Fear or Offerings and Seed Sowing to Bless You?

How to Spot When Faith Is Being Used for Financial Gain

Teach Them to Work With Their Hands — Not Just to Fast and Pray

How to Encourage Faith in God While Discouraging Joblessness and Unemployment in Believers

Other Related posts

Does God Need Your Fear or Offerings and Seed Sowing to Bless You?

How to Spot When Faith Is Being Used for Financial Gain

Teach Them to Work With Their Hands — Not Just to Fast and Pray

How to Encourage Faith in God While Discouraging Joblessness and Unemployment in Believers